LSE - Small Logo
LSE - Small Logo

Nafkote Dabi

November 19th, 2024

Billionaire ‘pollutocrats’ are driving the climate crisis – and with it inequality, hunger and heat-related deaths

0 comments | 6 shares

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes

Nafkote Dabi

November 19th, 2024

Billionaire ‘pollutocrats’ are driving the climate crisis – and with it inequality, hunger and heat-related deaths

0 comments | 6 shares

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes

If everyone used private jets and superyachts like the world’s richest billionaires, the remaining carbon budget to stay within 1.5C would be burned up in just two days. As COP29 draws to a close, Oxfam’s Nafkote Dabi asks: what is the scale of the problem of billionaires driving the climate crisis? And what should governments do in response?


The world’s richest people are using a disproportionate amount of the world’s remaining carbon budget and setting us all on course for irreversible and catastrophic global warming.

In Oxfam’s new climate report, published ahead of the UN COP29 climate conference, we show that if everyone began emitting as much carbon as those in the top 1%, the remaining carbon budget would be gone in fewer than five months. Or if everyone emitted carbon at the same rate as the luxury transport emissions of 50 of the world’s richest billionaires, the remaining carbon budget would be gone in two days.

The report builds on Oxfam’s previous research into the links between climate change and inequality, providing fresh evidence of how the very wealthiest “pollutocrats” are making a decisive contribution to planetary destruction. It signals that climate breakdown cannot be avoided without urgent action being taken to dramatically change the consumption and investment habits of the richest people.

Just 50 billionaires cause more damage than 155 million people

In the paper, we present new data on the luxury transport consumption – private jets and superyachts – and investment emissions of 50 of the world’s richest people. Our research finds that the transport and investment emissions from those 50 billionaires add up to more than the consumption emissions of the world’s poorest 2% (155 million people combined).

Oxfam identified private jets belonging to 23 of the 50 billionaires in the sample (the others either do not own jets or have kept them out of the public record). On average, these 23 billionaires each took 184 flights in 2023, emitting an average of 2,074 tonnes of carbon a year. This is equivalent to 300 years’ worth of emissions for the average person in the world, or 2,000 years for someone in the poorest 50%. Elon Musk alone owns (at least) two private jets which together produce 5,497 tonnes of CO2 per year.

On average, these billionaires took 184 flights on their private jets in 2023, emitting in one year carbon equivalent to what someone in the poorest 50% of the world would emit over 2,000 years

Oxfam also identified 23 superyachts owned by 18 billionaires and estimates the average annual carbon footprint of each these yachts to be 5,672 tonnes, more than three times the emissions of the billionaires’ private jets. This is equivalent to 860 years of emissions for the average person in the world, and 5,600 times the average of someone in the global poorest 50%. The Walton family, heirs to the Walmart retail chain, own three superyachts worth over $500 million which have a carbon footprint equivalent to around 1,700 of their shop workers.

luxury-super-yacht-image

The massive impact from super-rich people’s investments

Huge as the impact of luxury transport is, it is far exceeded by the investment footprint of the super-rich, which is the most important element of their overall impact on people and planet.

The report argues that we need to shine a spotlight on these investment emissions, since besides being big emitters from consumption, these billionaire investors own, control, shape and profit from the production processes that release so much of the globe’s greenhouse gases.

Of the 50 billionaires in our sample, Oxfam was able to identify the investment emissions of 41. The average investment emissions of these billionaires was 2.6 million tonnes of CO2e, (ie, equivalent to around 2.6 million tonnes of CO2). That is around 340 times the emissions from their private jets and superyachts combined.

How the emissions of the richest fuel inequality, hunger and death

The report goes on to spell out the impact of all these emissions of the super-rich, which are causing economic damage, particularly to poorer countries; driving up hunger; and fuelling excess deaths, typically as a result of extreme heat.

Hotter temperatures hurt annual economic growth, as they impact labour productivity, agricultural productivity, and energy use. New research for this paper shows that from 1990 to 2050, the economic cost of the super-rich 1% will add up to $52.6 trillion, with most of this cost borne by poorer countries. In fact, the damage already done to low- and lower-middle-income countries between 1990 and 2023 by the consumption emissions of the top 1% is about three times the total climate finance developed countries have given to poorer countries.

Climate change is also a leading cause of the steep rise in global hunger as it damages crop yields. Our report estimates that, by 2050, crop losses driven by decades of consumption emissions by the world’s richest 10% will be equivalent to losing enough food to feed a staggering 148.8 million people per year.

The final factor we look at in our report is excess deaths. Climate change is driving extreme heat and people’s risk of suffering potentially deadly heat-related illnesses. Our analysis shows that just four years (2015–2019) of the consumption emissions of the world’s richest 1% will be enough to cause 1.5 million excess deaths between 2020 and 2120. This equates to just over 15,000 excess deaths per year over the next century. That is higher than the current annual death toll due to natural disasters.

Three areas where governments must act urgently

Our report proposes three areas for urgent action:

1. Reduce the emissions of the richest

This can be done through several measures. First, producing and implementing just and ambitious climate plans to reduce emissions according to the requirements of the Paris Agreement – with emissions reductions based on individual incomes rather than national averages. Second, taxing the super-rich to curb their excessive consumption and investment emissions, and their role in propping up polluting industries. Third, banning or punitively taxing carbon-intensive luxury consumptions, starting with private jets, superyachts, sports utility vehicles (SUVs), and frequent air travel. And fourth, regulating corporations and investors in order to radically and fairly reduce their carbon emissions.

2. Make rich polluters pay

Governments must implement an ambitious package of progressive taxes on the income and wealth of the richest individuals and on the profits of the largest corporations, starting with windfall taxes. Without these, we will not be able to meet our huge climate finance needs. Oxfam estimates that low- and middle-income countries need at least $18.9 trillion between now and 2030 for climate action. In addition to this, there are civil society estimates that the Global North owes the Global South a climate debt of $5 trillion between 2025 and 2050 to compensate for their past exploitation of nature and people.

3. Reimagine our economies and societies to deliver wellbeing and planetary flourishing

To avert total climate breakdown also requires building new systems that prioritize human and planetary flourishing. The report therefore calls for governments to set targets to radically reduce economic inequality; go beyond the flawed goal of GDP growth and put new measures of progress at the heart of public policy that centre on equality, human wellbeing, and planetary health; reject neoliberal economics and put the state at the centre of delivering healthy and prosperous societies; and rebalance global institutions such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank and the World Trade Organization (WTO) to ensure that Global South countries have the autonomy and policy space to build a better future for their people.

Overall, then: as global temperatures continue to rise, risking the lives and livelihoods of people living in poverty and precarity, we must act now to curb the emissions of the super-rich and make rich polluters pay.

 


 

This post was originally published on Oxfam’s From Poverty to Power blog.

Sign up here to receive a monthly summary of blog posts from LSE Inequalities delivered direct to your inbox.

All articles posted on this blog give the views of the author(s). They do not represent the position of LSE Inequalities, nor of the London School of Economics and Political Science. 

Image credits: Juice Flair and Limbitech via Shutterstock.

About the author

Nafkote Dabi

Nafkote Dabi

Nafkote Dabi is the Climate Change Policy Lead at Oxfam International, where she works on the intersection of climate and inequality. She has co-authored influential reports, including "Climate Equality: A Planet for the 99%”. She is also the co-host of the EQUALS podcast, that explores inequality and solutions for a fairer world. She holds an MSc in International Social and Public Policy from LSE.

Posted In: Elites | Environment | Global Inequalities | Wealth

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *