LSE - Small Logo
LSE - Small Logo

Keith McDonald

July 1st, 2015

The paradoxical “selfishness” of aid – Karl Muth on stifling development

5 comments

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Keith McDonald

July 1st, 2015

The paradoxical “selfishness” of aid – Karl Muth on stifling development

5 comments

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

“Why do certain countries develop?” asks Karl Muth, a recent PhD graduate and now Lecturer in Economics, Public Policy and Statistics at Northwestern University.

In his TEDx talk, ‘International Development – Telling New Stories’, he delivers a complex answer derived from an anecdote that stems from fieldwork in Uganda.

Typically, answers vary. One answer a couple of decades ago may have been to embrace the free market. Others recommend increasing levels of aid.

Muth critiques the aid industry through the use of a simple, yet powerful story. In northern Uganda, where many aid agencies have been, he found that one could acquire almost anything free of charge.

What could sound better? Should we not be providing the impoverished with goods and services free of charge? Are we not, after all, attempting to show compassion to those who need it most?

Karl discovered the contrary whilst speaking to a father who wanted to discourage his nine year old daughter from becoming a doctor. The father explained that even with the best education and best training, how could his daughter create a living when services are being provided free of charge?

Even with the best qualifications, the local community are always going to choose the services which are made freely available from aid agencies. Ultimately, Muth argues, aid agencies are stifling local entrepreneurship and creativity.

What do these countries [the nine highest income countries since 1950] have in common? We notice that not one of these nine countries developed because of the kinds of aid we normally think of when we normally think of economic development aid. They didn’t receive or grow or do the things that we think that might happen in a developing country.

Too often we have allowed the effects of our programmes, to frustrate entrepreneurs, to stop people from being engineers and doctors.

Instead of a simple and pre-planned package to development, Muth argues for diverse and home-grown solutions.

Looking to historical examples, it is impossible to find a straightforward and easy method to development.

Historically, high income countries such as Israel, Argentina and Chile have all developed by utilising local entrepreneurship.

But the answer cannot be straightforward because development is far from an exact science. Rather, it’s an evolving pattern of dynamic responses to different kinds of adversity.

The answer may lie in less paternalistic intervention from developed nations. What we need is “new paths” and “new answers”. Contentiously made, Muth’s answer is the ingenuity of humanity.

Kris Gulati


Related Posts

No Wealth From Child Sacrifice (Credit: BBC)

About the author

Keith McDonald

Posted In: Department Alumni | Featured

5 Comments

RSS Justice and Security Research Programme

  • JSRP and the future
    The JSRP drew to a close in 2017 but many of the researchers and partners involved in the programme continue to work on the issues and theories developed during the lifetime of the programme. Tim Allen now directs the Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa (FLCA) at LSE where many of the JSRP research team working […]
  • Life after the LRA
    The JSRP reached the end of its grant in spring 2017 but several outputs from the programme are scheduled for publication in the coming months. The most recent of these is a new journal article from Holly Porter and Letha Victor drawing on their extensive research with JSRP in the Acholi region of northern Uganda.  The […]

RSS LSE’s engagement with South Asia

  • Four Stylised Facts about Covid-19 Impacts in Sri Lanka
    The Covid-19 pandemic has wreaked havoc for economies worldwide, and smaller countries have been hit particularly badly. Sri Lanka’s economy was already under stress but was slowly moving in the right direction when the combined effects of the pandemic on public health and the economy has dealt a severe blow. Ganeshan Wignaraja suggests possible ways […]
  • Bangladesh @ 50: Challenges to Inclusion
    While we celebrate Bangladesh’s achievements in economic growth and poverty reduction, a growth-focused strategy does not serve Bangabandhu’s vision for an egalitarian society as it excludes and neglects many citizens. As Bangladesh’s economy thrives, Mathilde Maitrot and Joe Devine’s research finds there are persistent pockets of extreme poverty, some of which are getting worse, and […]