LSE - Small Logo
LSE - Small Logo

Keith McDonald

October 14th, 2015

Is being more like China the answer for Britain? – Jude Howell

0 comments

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

Keith McDonald

October 14th, 2015

Is being more like China the answer for Britain? – Jude Howell

0 comments

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes

At last week’s Conservative Party conference, the Secretary for Health, Jeremy Hunt, urged the British population to “be prepared to work hard in a way that Asian economies are prepared to work hard”. His indirect reference to China must surely set alarm bells ringing amongst those who are familiar with the tale of “hard work” in China for the less well-off.

Jeremy Hunt, via Flickr (Ted Eytan: https://www.flickr.com/photos/taedc/8950255733/). Licence: CC BY-SA 2.0 (Image cropped)
UK Secretary of State for Health, Jeremy Hunt. Photo credit: Ted Eytan, via Flickr. Licence: CC BY-SA 2.0. Image cropped.

China has sustained historically phenomenal growth rates for over three decades. It has rapidly reduced poverty and raised the living standards of millions of people in China. This all deserves much praise and admiration.

However, this has not been without a price. There are huge environmental costs as anyone can testify who has experienced the lung-wrenching smogs that periodically blanket most major cities. The widening income inequalities mean that China is now one of the most unequal societies in the world.

But perhaps of most concern are the working conditions endured by millions of migrant workers whose toil and labour have built the glitzy high-rise buildings of Shanghai and Beijing, the high-speed rails that snake their way from north to south and the luxury villas that house China’s ultra-rich.

Despite China’s array of labour laws migrant workers in China continue to labour for seven days a week, often working 12-hour shifts for a wage that is little more than the local minimum. To be sure there has been some improvement over the years, particularly in higher-skilled industries where workers are better positioned to bargain for a higher wage.

But for the mass of rural migrant workers in China they continue to endure often militaristic-like factory regimes where even basic human functions such as going to the toilet are closely monitored. Furthermore, despite China having the world’s largest trade union, Chinese workers struggle to get their grievances addressed through official union channels. Not only do many private companies not tolerate the presence of unions, but where they do exist they are often headed by relatives of the owners or even the heads of human resources departments.

Moreover, since 2012 labour NGOs in China have been subject to constant harassment and threats of closure. It is not surprising then that China experiences strikes and work-place related protests on a daily basis.

Global-Tech, China. Photo credit: Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, via Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/nlcnet/8024490316. Licence: CC BY 2.0. Image cropped.
Global-Tech, China. Photo credit: Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, via Flickr. Licence: CC BY 2.0.

Apart from low wages and long working hours, Chinese workers endure poor health and safety environments. In 2014, according to official statistics, there were 68,061 workplace deaths, roughly 186 per day, more than occur in one year in the UK. Such deaths and accidents are not for want of legislation. At the end of 2014, an amended Work Safety Law came into force that obliges companies to make clear their work safety responsibility system.

How effective the amended law will be remains to be seen. However it will have to puncture the tight-knit web of interests between local governments and companies that have so often hindered workplace improvements in the past. The test of the pudding will be in whether injured workers have any better chance of gaining compensation for workplace injuries.

With so many workers now hired through sub-contracted agencies, often without a written employment contract, it has been difficult for workers to get basic proof of employment to even start processes of compensation.

There is nothing wrong with hard work. However, when the call for ‘hard work’ is more about a race to the bottom than about decent working conditions, then we need to heed with caution appeals to emulate the less endearing aspects of Chinese-style growth.

Professor Jude HowellJude Howell

Professor of International Development,
London School of Economics

(For more of her work on China and labour issues, see publications).


Related Posts

Global-Tech China. Photo credit: Institute for Global Labour and Human Rights, via Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/nlcnet/8024490316. Licence: CC BY 2.0.USA Flag (Photo Credit: Mike Mozart, via Flickr: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jeepersmedia/14325899679/) License: Attribution 2.0 Generic (CC BY 2.0)Kuala Lumpur City Centre Malaysia (Photo credit: Hadi Zaher via Flickr (https://www.flickr.com/photos/hazara/11446765955/) Shared via CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

About the author

Keith McDonald

Posted In: Featured | Topical and Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RSS Justice and Security Research Programme

  • JSRP and the future
    The JSRP drew to a close in 2017 but many of the researchers and partners involved in the programme continue to work on the issues and theories developed during the lifetime of the programme. Tim Allen now directs the Firoz Lalji Centre for Africa (FLCA) at LSE where many of the JSRP research team working […]
  • Life after the LRA
    The JSRP reached the end of its grant in spring 2017 but several outputs from the programme are scheduled for publication in the coming months. The most recent of these is a new journal article from Holly Porter and Letha Victor drawing on their extensive research with JSRP in the Acholi region of northern Uganda.  The […]

RSS LSE’s engagement with South Asia

  • Growing up in a Digital World: Vulnerabilities of Children in post-Pandemic India
    The closing down of schools during the Covid-19 pandemic meant a complete reliance on online teaching for students to ensure that formal education remained as little disrupted as possible. Simultaneously, remaining at home for extended periods of time meant that children were spending more and more time online, for socialisation and entertainment. This has inevitably […]
  • ‘Haqiqi’ (True) Development: Communities Coming Together for Polio Immunisation in Pakistan
    Pakistan is one of only two countries in the world (along with Afghanistan) which is yet to eradicate the highly infectious Wild Polio Virus (WPV1). In this post, Tahira Ali, Savaila Hunzai and Zahra Rao outline how locally-rooted, empathetic and culturally sensitive practices can help overcome barriers, and help increase the percentage of polio vaccination […]